The evidence for what makes psychotherapy work 2nd ed. The great psychotherapy debate, second edition the great psychotherapy debate, second edition. Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change 5th ed. Demonstrating that the specific ingredients of a treatment are responsible for the benefits of counseling and psychotherapy is.
Read download the great psychotherapy debate pdf pdf download. The great psychotherapy debate counseling and psychotherapy. The evidence for what makes psychotherapy work bruce e. Not surprisingly, therapist effects in naturalistic settings are greater than in clinical trials.
The great psychotherapy debate university of wisconsin. Kop the great psychotherapy debate av bruce e wampold, zac e imel pa. Psychotherapy researchers bruce wampold and peter fonagy meet at the nordic conference of mental health schizofrenidagene. Imel the second edition of the great psychotherapy debate has been updated and revised to expand the presentation of the contextual model, which is derived from a scientific understanding of how humans heal in a social context and explains. In it wampold, who has a degree in mathematics and who went on to train as a counseling psychologist, reported that psychotherapy is indeed effective, the. Psychotherapy debate with peter fonagy and bruce wampold at the nordic conference on mental health. The role of leaders working alliance in premarital education. A supervisory extrapolation of the wampold budge psychotherapy relationship model.
The evidence for what makes psychotherapy work with z. And they get significantly better with an effect sizeb etween. Estimating variability in outcomes attributable to therapists. Miller and bruce e wampold and katelyn varhely, journal psychotherapy research. So, the debate is about what makes psychotherapy works, best characterized by a debate.
Research has more recently focused on what factors contribute to psychotherapy success. Psychotherapy debate with peter fonagy and bruce wampold. Presents 2 competing models of psychotherapy the medical model, which focuses on the specificity of treatments, and the contextual model, which emphasizes the commonality among therapies. With scrupulous care and unquestioned fairness, bruce wampold has assumed the mantle of foremost proponent of the general factors explanation for psychotherapy efficacy. Lots of discussion about this yes psychotherapy works does one work better than othermixed results.
The second edition of bruce wampold s, the great psychotherapy debate. His work is summarized in the forthcoming volume great psychotherapy debate with z. With scrupulous care and unquestioned fairness, bruce wampold has assumed the. Wampold has done the profession a major service with the publication of this book. In it wampold, who has a degree in mathematics and who went on to train as a counseling psychologist, reported that psychotherapy is indeed effective, the type of treatment is not a factor. If youre a member of the society for the advancement of psychotherapy you can access the psychotherapy article via your apa member page. Nov 01, 2008 the second edition of the great psychotherapy debate has been updated and revised to expand the presentation of the contextual model, which is derived from a scientific understanding of how humans heal in a social context and explains findings from a vast array of psychotherapies studies. Evidencebased psychotherapy means evidenceinformed, not. Learning from the fields most effective practitioners. The theoretical orientation shapes the personality of the. I was eager to read this 2nd edition as soon as it came out.
Fonagy and allison recently published an article titled the role of mentalizing and epistemic trust in the therapeutic relationship in psychotherapy. Method twentythree participants with gad of at least moderate severity were randomized to 12 individual sessions of the sbi n 11 or supportive psychotherapy sp our control condition n 12. Direct comparisons of treatment modalities for youth disorders. Epistemic trust, psychopathology and the great psychotherapy.
About 50% of patients get better if they engage in therapy and do not drop out prematurely. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Norcross jc 2011 psychotherapy relationships that work, 2. American psychiatric association, washington wampold be 2001 the great psychotherapy debate. The metaanalytical type of research has proved no significant differences in terms of efficiency of the different forms of psychotherapy wampold, 2001, drisko 2004. In 2001, he published the book the great psychotherapy debate. Models, methods, and findings counseling and psychotherapy. The first edition of the great psychotherapy debate served as a gauge tossed at the feet of the prevailing medical model of psychotherapy. Since 1960, it has been applied accurate, focused and controlled standards to evaluate the. Wampold page 2 2001 diplomate in counseling psychology, american board of professional. This model provides a compelling alternative to traditional research on psychotherapy, which tends to focus. The great psychotherapy debate, as the sub title of the book the evidence for what makes psychotherapy work indicates, is about how exactly psychotherapy works and what research tells us about different types of treatment, including psychiatric drugs from an historical and anthropological point of view.
In most studies of treatment conducted over the last 40 years, the average treated person is. Professor wampold cogently brought together the literature in the area and provided a compelling option to the empirically supported movement. The common factors have a long history in the field of psychotherapy. The great psychotherapy debate bruce e wampold, zac e imel. Your fantastic book, the great psychotherapy debate. The first edition of the great psychotherapy debate 2001 has become a classic in the field, and has had a major impact on the field of psychotherapy research as influencing the practices of managed care companies and other payers. Sep 16, 2016 bruce wampold on qualities and actions of effective therapists and expertise research. For human development processes, human change and learning processes, the dynamics and prognosis of mental disorders, problems manifesting in social systems such as couples, families, teams, or the question of how.
The evidence for what makes psychotherapy work, has been updated and revised to expand the presentation of the contextual model, which is derived from a scientific understanding of how humans heal in a social context and explains findings from a vast array of psychotherapies studies. I believe that it is a classicthe net result of this work is that it gives psychotherapists a hook, something upon which to hang their hats, in that it refines and defines the path of psychotherapy research and practice for. The second edition of the great psychotherapy debate has been updated and revised to expand the presentation of the contextual model, which is derived from a scientific understanding of how humans heal in a social context and explains findings from a vast array of psychotherapies studies. Dodo birds, a golden thread, and empirically supported therapy. Pdf the great psychotherapy debate download full pdf. Bruce wampold is a clinical psychologist at the university of wisconsin. Nov 16, 2016 psychotherapy researchers bruce wampold and peter fonagy meet at the nordic conference of mental health schizofrenidagene. Investigating practice from sc 1 by wampold, bruce e. Feb 24, 2015 the first edition of the great psychotherapy debate served as a gauge tossed at the feet of the prevailing medical model of psychotherapy.
This cited by count includes citations to the following articles in scholar. In the seminal book, the great psychotherapy debate, wampold 2001. The great psychotherapy debate does not break new ground. The great psychotherapy debate maastricht university. The great psychotherapy debate psychotherapeutische praxis. On the one side were those who contended that the rate o f suc cess o f psychotherapy was less than or equal to the rate o f spontaneous remission. Wampold and others published the great psychotherapy debate. His work is summarized in the great psychotherapy debate. Using outcomes measures in outpatient psychotherapy.
Stich, kurt p benson, hyunnie ahn 1997 this rectaanalysis tested the dodo bird conjecture, which states that when psychotherapies intended to be therapeutic are compared, the true differences among all such treatments are 0. Currently his work involves understanding psychotherapy from empirical, historical, and anthropological perspectives, which has led to the development of a contextual model of psychotherapy. Are randomized controlled trials relevant to clinical. Bruce wampold zette deze discussie op scherp met zijn boek the great psychotherapy. The second edition of bruce wampolds, the great psychotherapy debate. It seems therefore obvious that most of the phenomena that psychology and psychotherapy are concerned with are dynamic in nature. In it wampold, a former statistician studying primarily outcomes with depressed patients, reported that 1 psychotherapy can be more effective than placebo, 2 no single treatment modality has the edge in efficacy, and 3 factors common to. Common factors theory has been dominated by research on psychotherapy process and outcome variables, and there is a need for further work explaining the mechanisms of psychotherapy common factors in terms of emerging theoretical and empirical research in the neurosciences and social sciences, just as earlier works such as dollard and millers.
Bruce wampold on qualities and actions of effective. Cabaran pegawai psikologi di penjara challenges of. Read download the great psychotherapy debate pdf pdf. Randomized controlled trials are relevant to clinical practice ithink that randomized controlled trials rcts are highly relevant to clinical practice. Investigating practice from sc by wampold, bruce e. This finding generalizes across a wide range of disorders and different therapy formats, including individual, couple, family, and group therapies. The great psychotherapy debate models, methods, and findings. Pdf the great psychotherapy debate download full pdf book. Terms in this set 12 the great psychotherapy debate bruce e.
Direct comparisons of treatment modalities for youth. Complexity and nonlinear dynamics in psychotherapy. I argue that it is unethical to try to impose est criteria on the field of psychotherapy practice when a there is considerable controversy over these criteria, b there are alternative ways to construe evidencebased practice, and c by other criteria many. Means or methods goals, meaning or purpose clients view of the therapeutic relationship clientr preferences j our n a lf c st i gd cp yh, 64 the heart and soul of change. Wolleat professor of counseling psychology and clinical professor of psychiatry at the university of wisconsinmadison. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.
Wampold, 9780805857085, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Uwmadison department of counseling psychology faculty. Psychotherapy debate with peter fonagy and bruce wampold at. The second edition of the great psychotherapy debate has been updated and revised to expand the presentation of the contextual model, which is derived from a scientific understanding of how humans heal in a social.
Bruce, youve been in the field of psychotherapy for over 30 years and have made a tremendous contribution to our understanding of psychotherapy from empirical, historical, and anthropological perspectives through what you call the contextual model of psychotherapy. Some advocates of empiricallysupported treatments ests argue that practitioners who do not use them are practicing unethically. The first edition of the great psychotherapy debate 2001 has become a classic in. The golden thread that unifies effective treatments by j. In debate are randomized controlled trials relevant to clinical practice.
Research evidence for what works in psychotherapy 2nd ed. From a scientific perspective, the specific ingredient versus common factor polemic should be settled empirically rather than rhetorically. Estimating variability in outcomes attributable to. Wampold is known for developing the contextual model of psychotherapy, which constitutes an alternative to the prevailing theory of the effectiveness of psychotherapy, known as the medical model. How important are the common factors in psychotherapy.
693 319 889 1185 908 409 179 737 572 649 253 1238 449 1067 351 568 275 1284 722 622 1045 411 1409 1205 1100 1563 1369 15 274 633 1302 123 1047 991 372 36 8 60 529 460 538 872 19 143 1173 1383